Sport:

East Columbus at Chatham Central: Stats, Matchup Breakdown and Prediction

Screenshot

The Gators take their most wins since 2013 and a different starting quarterback to Bear Creek for a rematch with unbeaten Chatham Central.

Chatham Central needed nearly 39 minutes to put East Columbus away in September. The Bears led 6-0 until a second touchdown with 9:34 left sealed a 14-0 win in Lake Waccamaw. A week later, East Columbus moved senior receiver Demetrius Dexter to quarterback.

Tonight, the Bears get their first look at the Gators with Dexter starting under center. And East Columbus gets a shot at a round it has never reached in the available playoff records.

No. 5 East Columbus (5-6) AT No. 1 Chatham Central (11-0)
7 p.m. Friday, Nov. 20 | Bear Creek | NCHSAA 1A West third round
The winner faces Wilson Prep or Robbinsville for the West title.

The first meeting: Four sacks, no points

Brooks Albright threw both Chatham Central touchdowns to Gavin Williams, from 23 yards in the first quarter and seven yards in the fourth. He also ran for 68 yards. East Columbus defensive lineman Jacob Stukes recorded 11 tackles and four sacks. Dawson Crosby added seven tackles, a sack and a forced fumble. Dexter recovered a fumble.

Four sacks from Stukes helped hold Chatham Central to its lowest scoring output in a game it played all season. Excluding a 2-0 forfeit win, the Bears have averaged 34.2 points and allowed 12.0 in 10 games, with three shutouts. East Columbus already knows it can disrupt this offense. The bigger question is whether it can finish drives of its own.

Dexter changed what East Columbus can do

Dexter’s first start at Whiteville ended in a 41-0 loss. In the next five games, he topped 100 combined passing and rushing yards every time:

  • Hobbton: 44 passing, 60 rushing.
  • Union: 46 passing, 129 rushing.
  • West Columbus: 86 passing, 72 rushing.
  • East Bladen: 180 passing, 176 rushing.
  • North Duplin: 130 passing, 84 rushing, plus a 55-yard touchdown catch.

That’s 1,007 yards in five games: 486 passing and 521 rushing. Dexter accounted for all three Gators touchdowns in the 22-20 loss at East Bladen, where East Columbus trailed 22-8 entering the fourth and was stopped on a potential tying conversion. He threw, ran and caught a touchdown in the 23-8 win over North Duplin. Christan Norton threw Dexter the 55-yard score and ran for 77 yards himself. East Columbus held North Duplin to 121 yards.

Across those two games, Dexter totaled 570 yards passing and rushing, or 625 with the touchdown catch. That two-game split shows where he fits in the program’s recent history. J.R. Stewart threw for 361 yards in back-to-back games in 2021 and finished with 986 passing yards and 11 touchdowns in eight reported games. Dexter threw for 310 against East Bladen and North Duplin and added 260 on the ground. East Columbus has had bigger two-game rushing stretches, too: Davonte Marshburn opened 2023 with 370 yards, Trumal Baldwin had 268 in 2016, and Crosby ran for more than 350 over two playoff games last fall. Dexter’s distinction is how much he produced both ways.

Lakewood still shut out East Columbus 14-0 in the regular-season finale. But against Winston-Salem Prep, Dexter threw for about 100 yards, Norton ran for about 100 on 14 carries and Crosby caught a touchdown that made it 20-8. The Gators won 20-14 and held Prep to 16 rushing yards. Dexter also enters this rematch with nine interceptions, the most on MaxPreps’ reported 1A leaderboard.

Crosby’s impact goes well beyond his 124 tackles

A year ago, Crosby was the quarterback carrying East Columbus into the third round. He ran 49 times for more than 300 yards and four touchdowns, threw a touchdown to Stukes and scored the final two-point conversion in a 32-21 playoff win at North Stokes. He finished with 1,002 rushing yards and 12 rushing touchdowns, plus 347 passing yards, in 11 reported games.

This year, Crosby has 20 catches for 359 yards and three touchdowns. Against West Columbus and East Bladen alone, he had seven catches for 155 yards and 29 tackles. He made 69 tackles over five straight games, with at least 13 in each.

His 124 tackles in 11 games lead the current MaxPreps 1A list. Add 58 reported as a sophomore and 46 as a junior, and Crosby has at least 228 documented varsity tackles. That’s a verified total, not a school-record claim. The linebacker earned an East-West All-Star selection alongside Gators defensive lineman Pa’tron Dixon.

Two close calls show where Chatham can be tested

Derrin Little’s Bears went 1-10 last year. This fall, they put together the program’s first unbeaten regular season and won its first conference title. Albright has 1,577 passing yards, 23 touchdown passes and four interceptions, plus 480 yards and 10 touchdowns on the ground in 10 reported games. Williams has 28 catches for 604 yards and nine scores, averaging 21.6 yards per catch. Nolan Mitchell has seven touchdown catches, and Tyler Congrove has five interceptions.

Albright went 10 of 13 for 142 yards and two touchdowns and ran eight times for 76 yards and two more scores in the 40-0 playoff win over College Prep. But the Bears’ two closest games show how opponents made things harder.

Winston-Salem Prep, 30-24: Jamari Wilson ran for 181 yards on 18 carries and threw for 155 yards and two touchdowns. Elijah Skinner caught five passes for 115 yards. Chatham’s offense finished with 195 yards, including 101 passing and 65 rushing from Albright. The Bears needed Matthew Victorino’s 90-yard interception return for a touchdown, a 2-yard Albright keeper to tie it with just over a minute left, and a Mitchell interception to set up Williams’ winning catch with four seconds left. Both East Columbus and Chatham won at Prep by six. What matters more for this matchup is the 336 yards Wilson produced as a runner and passer.

South Stokes, 20-19: The submitted box score credits the Sauras with 203 rushing yards on 30 carries. Quarterback Luke Amos ran for more than 100 yards and two touchdowns, and Kymani Brown added 83 yards and a score. Amos broke a long run on a 99-yard touchdown drive, and South Stokes’ formations and motion forced Chatham to adjust during the game. On offense, the Bears managed seven first-half points. Two Albright interceptions set up second-half touchdowns and a 19-14 South Stokes lead. Albright scored on a 10-yard keeper with 3:10 left, and the Bears still had to stop a fourth-down pass from their 23 with 16 seconds left.

The common thread is the quarterback run. Both Wilson and Amos topped 100 yards on the ground. Norton can make Chatham defend the middle, and Dexter can punish the edge when it closes down. The Gators can’t afford the mistake that bailed Chatham out against Prep: a turnover that puts points on the board before the Bears’ offense has to take the field.

What a sixth win would mean

East Columbus has already won at Chatham Central. The Gators beat the Bears 22-20 in Bear Creek on Sept. 5, 2025, ending a 17-game losing streak. Norton tied it in the final minute, and Crosby ran in the winning two-point conversion. The teams have split the two meetings that appear in East Columbus’s schedule archives back through 2004.

Last week’s fifth win was the program’s first since 2013, when the Gators also earned No. 5 on the road in the playoffs, 40-22 at North Edgecombe. Under first-year coach Vinston Thorpe, East Columbus has cut its points allowed from 35.7 per game last year to 18.2 this year. No opponent has scored more than 14 in any of its five wins.

The Gators beat Bear Grass Charter 28-6 in the 2022 playoffs and reached the third round last year before losing 54-7 to Robbinsville. Toby Kasell’s nine-win 2012 team beat North Stokes 52-6 and South Stanly 66-20 before falling 19-18 to unbeaten Albemarle in the third round. A win tonight would give East Columbus its first documented fourth-round berth and its first six-win season since 2012.

The pick: East Columbus 22, Chatham Central 20

I’m taking East Columbus. Get Norton going early, let Dexter keep it when Chatham closes inside, and give Crosby and JT Hudson a chance downfield when the secondary steps up. On defense, pressure Albright without giving him a lane to run. Make the Bears drive the field instead of letting Williams get behind the coverage.

The Gators don’t need Dexter to put up another 356-yard night. They need to finish the drives they couldn’t finish in September. This time, they have the quarterback and the running game to do it.